To get the most out of the Quantm system, be clear about the planning objectives and be willing to investigate and select route alignments unhindered by conventional practices that may lead to biased opinions of where the optimal alignment should lie.
Ensure that a feasible alignment is possible
Trimble Alignment Planning software can identify a feasible alignment and then optimize it. However, if the constraints applied to the study do not allow a feasible alignment to exist, the software may generate undesirable results.
Common examples of conflict
-
Requiring a road to pass under a railway line at the same time that it has to maintain a minimum altitude while crossing a flood plain.
-
Requiring a road and its earthworks to stay within a narrow corridor as it climbs a mountain with a low maximum grade. The road requires distance to climb, but the narrow corridor limits winding, and the grade constraint forces the alignment so far below the natural surface that the earthworks extend beyond the corridor.
The solution is to gradually add constraints to a project, one after another. You can then identify and correct constraints that may have a negative effect on the system as they arise.
Judge alignment solutions subjectively
There is a large subjective element in planning. The planner may be required to find an optimal alignment that balances low cost with non-quantitative factors, such as how the route impacts the environment and community.
This process of minimizing costs while preserving environmental amenities can be complex, leading to difficult questions about how environmental impact is measured and how it is balanced against objective costs.
Strategies
To manage this, you can follow one of these principles:
-
Assign monetary values to the areas of environmental importance and then incorporate them into the objective function. It may be possible (though difficult and costly) to allocate a monetary value to each square meter (yard) of a National Park based on the impact that the alienation of that square meter (yard) would have on the integrity of the park. However, this does not address the more difficult problem of the impact of the alignment on the contiguity of the Park. There is also the difficulty that any interested party that disagrees with the result will contest the values assigned to the subjective factors, arguing for an increase or decrease depending on how they want the answer changed.
-
Recognize that environmental impact is essentially multi-dimensional and that any judgment about the value of environmental amenities also involves judgments about the relative value of different aspects of the environment. Determine whether a conflict exists and, if it does, what additional objective costs would be imposed on the alignment by avoiding the environmentally sensitive area completely. If this is considered excessive, various compromises can be investigated. This (favored) strategy is based on the view that computer packages should not make decisions that are essentially subjective; rather they should be used to generate objective information which can be used by planners
Every result tells you something
Sometimes when processing, you will see results that are unexpected or undesirable. It is important in cases like this not to disregard these results, but in fact, to work through and try to identify why the results are doing what they are doing. Taking the time to understand why a result has done what it has done can reveal as much information as looking at a result set that has worked. It is also important to check everything that has gone into the scenario when checking results. While sometimes there are obvious issues in a scenario, this may not be the only issue in the scenario, and taking the time to check may mean time is saved later with subsequent submissions. When looking at undesirable results, it is important to understand how features have reacted with the geometric constraints, and also how costs have combined to impact the results. Of course, if there is a problem and you can't identify what is going on, don't hesitate to contact Trimble Planning Solutions to help identify what has gone on.
Start planning as early as possible
You do not need to wait until detailed data is available. Coarse data and assumed parameters can narrow the corridor, and greatly reduce the area over which detailed information has to be collected.
Planning is an iterative process. The first plans are usually conceptual and based on coarse data and assumed parameters and constraints but, as you proceed, planning becomes more focused and requires more detailed and accurate information. The Quantm system is extremely flexible in the demands it places upon data and in its ability to satisfy diverse constraints. Data requirements tend to be of the form “If you want to take this constraint into consideration, you must provide the following information”. If you do not have the information, the constraint cannot be applied.